Practiceby Lab 10 Get started ›
Crossfire

Are cold showers and saunas worth doing for your nervous system?

What the experts say

Dan HarrisJournalist and author · former ABC News anchor · no clinical, research or teaching credential claimed

Probably worth the 15 seconds, with the mechanism story held loosely

What it rests onHe finishes his daily shower with 15 seconds of cold after interviewing a vagus nerve researcher, is building towards 30 to 60 seconds, and links a Harvard Health summary plus a paper on facial cold contact. In the same post he writes the caveat himself: these practices 'may help regulate the nervous system in the moment; whether they literally increase vagal tone over time is a harder scientific question.'

Source: danharris.substack.com ↗
Andrea LovePhD · immunologist and microbiologist

The cold and heat literature does not support the claims made for it, and cold immersion carries real risk

What it rests onHer argument: the cold plunge studies conflict (one study of 10 athletes found a small white cell rise, another found nothing, a Dutch randomised trial found 30 percent fewer sickness absences but no reduction in days feeling unwell); sudden immersion below 60F can kill in under a minute; the usually cited sauna study had 20 male participants aged 20 to 25 and a population likely confounded by income, diet and exercise.

Source: See lov-coldplunge-immune in docs/experts/love-corpus.md for her sourcing

Overview

Different exposures and different outcomes. Harris is describing 15 seconds of cold water at the end of a warm shower, aimed at how he feels; Love is assessing cold water immersion and sauna as immune interventions. The risk half of her argument applies to immersion, not to a cold shower; the evidence half applies to both.

Where they agree

Both hold that the mechanism claims circulating about these practices outrun the evidence. Harris says so in the same post in which he recommends the practice, which is worth knowing.

What would settle it

Adequately powered randomised trials of brief cold exposure with pre-registered wellbeing or autonomic endpoints, and sauna cohorts that handle socioeconomic confounding. Both sides have said the current evidence would not survive that.

Practice does not pick a winner here

You do, and your call is dated, kept, and yours to change. Follow the people you already trust and what they publish turns into a short daily practice.

Get started

Free to sign up and use. We do not ask for a card.